THREAD: dramatic judge threatens trump gop probes
LifeLine™ Media threads use our sophisticated algorithms to construct a thread around any topic you want, providing you with a detailed timeline, analysis, and related articles.
News Timeline
TRUMP Assassination Attempt SUSPECT Laughs in Court: Shocking Behavior Revealed
— Ryan W. Routh, accused of trying to assassinate former President Trump, appeared in court Monday. He was seen smiling and laughing with his defense lawyers. Florida prosecutor Dave Aronberg stated that Routh’s behavior does not indicate criminal insanity. “He fled after all, tried to get away and escape,” Aronberg noted. Routh was arrested near Palm City, Florida on September 15, 2024. A U.S. Secret Service agent spotted a rifle barrel through a fence at Trump International Golf Club in West Palm Beach. Routh fled north on Interstate 95 toward his home in North Carolina. Aronberg highlighted the irony of Routh’s actions given his support for Ukraine against Russia. Despite understanding right from wrong in international conflicts, Routh allegedly attempted an evil act by targeting Trump. This undermines any potential insanity defense he might claim. Federal prosecutors have taken over the case as the investigation continues into the failed assassination plot against former President Trump.
Heightened security measures marked the event, reflecting increased threat levels. Trump focused on resilience and overcoming adversity in his speech, themes that resonated with supporters. This appearance is significant as Trump had been relatively quiet since the incident.
President Biden praised law enforcement for their heroic response, highlighting their role in maintaining public safety. Figures from both political sides acknowledged the bravery of the security forces involved. Investigations continue to uncover more details about the suspect and their motives.
The incident has sparked discussions about security protocols for public figures amid political tension. Trump’s return is seen as a defiant stand against threats to democracy and personal safety. The event underscores the volatile environment of contemporary American politics as investigations proceed.
ANOTHER ATTEMPT on Trump’s Life: FBI Investigates Alleged Assassination
— Former President Donald Trump survived another alleged assassination attempt while golfing in West Palm Beach on Sunday. The FBI is investigating the incident as an “attempted assassination.” This comes just over eight weeks after Trump narrowly survived a shooting at a campaign rally in Butler, Pennsylvania.
Former UK Prime Minister Liz Truss expressed relief that Trump is safe, questioning the state of affairs in the U.S. “These attempts to subvert democracy must be stopped,” she urged. UK Home Secretary Yvette Cooper also condemned the violence, stating political violence has no place in a democracy and expressing gladness for Trump’s safety.
Nigel Farage, leader of Reform UK and a staunch Trump ally, called the shooting “truly appalling.” Farage himself has faced physical attacks due to his political career and reflected on this latest attempt on Trump’s life with concern. Since leaving office, Liz Truss has become one of Trump’s most vocal supporters in Europe, emphasizing the importance of his return to power for the fate of the Western world.
TOP FEDERAL Prosecutor Caught In Shocking Drunken HIT-And-RUN
— A top federal narcotics prosecutor, Joseph Ruddy, violated ethics rules during a hit-and-run investigation last year. Ruddy, visibly intoxicated, handed his business card to Florida police officers after crashing into another vehicle and fleeing the scene. The Justice Department’s Office of Inspector General confirmed he misused his position as an assistant U.S. attorney in Tampa.
Body-camera footage from the Fourth of July incident shows Ruddy struggling to stand and slurring his words while leaning on his pickup truck for balance. Despite his condition, he presented his Justice Department credentials to officers from two jurisdictions investigating the crash. A Tampa police officer warned him that the footage would not look good when reviewed later.
The Justice Department’s report found that Ruddy engaged in conduct prejudicial to the government by driving drunk and leaving the scene of an accident. The case has been referred to the Professional Misconduct Review Unit for further action.
Although removed from several cases following inquiries about his status, Ruddy remains an assistant U.S. attorney as of Wednesday. Neither he nor his attorney has responded to requests for comment on this matter.
BIDEN DEMANDS Supreme Court Shake-UP: Sparks Intense Debate
— President Biden has called for major changes to the Supreme Court, sparking a heated debate. Co-host Jonathan Lemire discussed the topic with Senator Cory Booker, who downplayed the extent of the proposed reforms.
Booker argued that these changes are practical and have bipartisan support. He emphasized that the highest court should not have low ethics standards, pointing out that right-wing billionaires are giving lavish gifts to justices with cases before the court.
Booker also supported term limits for justices, similar to other major democracies. He stressed that courts should not be influenced by financial gifts from interested parties as this undermines democracy and delegitimizes institutions.
CONGRESS BLOCKED From Trump Rally Security Report
— Congress was blocked from accessing the crucial Ops Report detailing the protection plan for former President Trump’s rally, a lawmaker revealed to Fox News Digital. The report should explain who was responsible for securing the rooftop from which Thomas Matthew Crooks fired.
Paul Mauro, an attorney and retired NYPD inspector, stated that if the Ops Plan did not cover that rooftop or wasn’t done at all, it represents a significant failure by whoever approved it. Mauro confirmed that as of Thursday afternoon, the FBI held the detailed written plan based on information from a highly trusted source.
The FBI declined to comment on the matter. Despite several reported sightings of Crooks an hour before he opened fire in Butler, Pennsylvania, he managed to slip through security cracks. One of his bullets grazed Trump’s ear and could have been fatal if Trump hadn’t moved his head at that moment.
SENATOR Menendez CONVICTED: Corruption Verdict Shocks Nation
— U.S. Sen. Bob Menendez was convicted of accepting bribes and acting as a foreign agent for Egypt. Prosecutors said he abused his office to protect allies and enrich associates, including his wife.
Menendez, 70, vowed to appeal the verdict, claiming he never violated his public oath or acted as a foreign agent. He did not testify during the nine-week trial but insisted publicly that he was only doing his job as chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee.
The conviction comes just four months before Election Day, likely ending Menendez’s chances of reelection as an independent. Prominent Democrats, including Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer and Rep. Andy Kim, have called for his resignation following the verdict.
MADURO SHOCKS With Sympathy for Trump After Assassination Attempt
— Former President Donald Trump survived an assassination attempt during a rally in Butler, Pennsylvania. The shooter injured Trump and killed Corey Comperatore, a former fire chief.
Venezuelan dictator Nicolás Maduro condemned the attack on Trump during his own campaign rally. Maduro’s comments were unusually sympathetic towards Trump, wishing him a "speedy recovery.
Maduro stated, “We have been adversaries but I wish President Trump health and a long life.” This marks a significant shift from his typical hostile rhetoric against the former U.S. president.
SUPREME COURT Shocker: Emergency Abortions Allowed in Idaho
— The Supreme Court is set to permit emergency abortions in Idaho when a pregnant patient’s health is at serious risk. A draft opinion briefly posted on the court’s website indicates a 6-3 vote to reinstate a lower court order allowing such procedures. Conservative Justices Thomas, Alito, and Gorsuch dissented.
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson noted that this decision does not resolve the core issues of Idaho’s strict abortion ban. She emphasized that today’s ruling is merely a delay, not a victory for pregnant patients in Idaho. The case will continue at the 9th U.S. Circuit Court and may return to the Supreme Court later.
The Supreme Court acknowledged an inadvertent posting of the document and stated that an official opinion would be issued “in due course.” This development leaves many key questions unanswered, prolonging uncertainty around Idaho’s abortion laws.
DEMOCRATIC CHAOS in New Jersey Politics: What It Means for November
— The indictment of Democratic power broker George E. Norcross III on racketeering charges marks a significant blow to New Jersey’s dominant political party. State Attorney General Matt Platkin accused Norcross of orchestrating tax benefits for entities he controlled, which Norcross vehemently denied. This comes amid ongoing federal bribery charges against Democratic Sen. Bob Menendez, who has pleaded not guilty.
These legal troubles add to the turbulence in New Jersey politics just months before the November general election. Democrats are now scrambling to hold onto a U.S. Senate seat they didn’t expect to fight for, as their thin majority is already at risk. Republicans see new opportunities to gain a seat they haven’t held in over fifty years, buoyed by the chaos within the Democratic Party.
Some progressives view this upheaval as an overdue cleanup of New Jersey’s messy political landscape, long dominated by Democrats. Others draw parallels with national Republican dynamics, where establishment power has given way to populism championed by figures like former President Donald Trump. They see it as a potential shift towards restoring power to the people across the political spectrum.;
TRUMP FIGHTS Back: Lawyers Demand End to GAG Order in New York Case
— Donald Trump’s legal team is requesting the removal of a gag order that prevents him from commenting on witnesses, jurors, and others involved in his criminal case. His lawyers argue that the restrictions on Trump’s First Amendment rights are no longer justified now that the trial has concluded.
Trump’s attorneys, Todd Blanche and Emil Bove, emphasized the need for “unrestrained campaign advocacy,” especially after President Joe Biden’s public comments about the verdict. They also pointed out ongoing criticism from Michael Cohen and Stormy Daniels as reasons to lift the gag order.
The Manhattan district attorney’s office declined to comment on this request. Judge Juan M. Merchan initially issued the gag order before the trial started due to concerns about Trump attacking those involved in his cases.
Merchan later expanded it to include comments about his own family after Trump targeted his daughter online. While remarks about Merchan and District Attorney Alvin Bragg are permitted, statements regarding court staff and Bragg’s prosecution team remain prohibited under the current gag order.
NPR BIAS Scandal: Calls for Defunding Surge as Political Imbalance Revealed**
— Senator Marsha Blackburn aligns with former President Trump, advocating for the defunding of NPR due to perceived bias. This push gains momentum following the resignation of NPR editor Uri Berliner, who exposed a stark political imbalance within the organization’s Washington, DC office. Berliner disclosed that among 87 registered voters at NPR, not one is a registered Republican.
NPR’s chief news executive Edith Chapin contested these allegations, asserting the network’s dedication to nuanced and inclusive reporting. Despite this defense, Senator Blackburn condemned NPR for its lack of conservative representation and scrutinized the justification for funding it with taxpayer dollars.
Uri Berliner, while opposing defunding efforts and commending his colleagues’ integrity, resigned amid concerns over media impartiality. He expressed his hope that NPR would maintain its commitment to significant journalism amidst ongoing debates about its political orientation.
This controversy spotlights broader issues regarding media bias and taxpayer funding in public broadcasting sectors, questioning whether public funds should support organizations perceived as politically skewed.
TRUMP SURGES Ahead in Michigan: Biden’s Struggle to Secure Base Exposed
— A recent trial ballot in Michigan has revealed a surprising lead for Trump over Biden, with 47 percent favoring the former president compared to 44 percent for the incumbent. This result falls within the survey’s ±3 percent margin of error, leaving nine percent of voters still undecided.
In a more complex five-way trial ballot test, Trump maintains his lead at 44 percent against Biden’s 42 percent. The remaining votes are split among independent Robert F. Kennedy Jr., Green Party candidate Dr. Jill Stein, and independent Cornel West.
Steve Mitchell, president of Mitchell Research, attributes Trump’s lead to Biden’s lackluster support from African Americans and younger voters. He forecasts a nail-biting contest ahead as the victory will likely hinge on which candidate can rally their base more effectively.
In a head-to-head choice between Trump and Biden, an overwhelming 90 percent of Republican Michiganders back Trump while only 84 percent of Democrats support Biden. This poll report underscores an uncomfortable situation for Biden as he loses a significant 12 percent chunk of his vote to former President Trump.
GOP’S SELF-Destruction: Gowdy Slams Republican Candidate Choices and Election Failures
— In a thought-provoking exchange, host Rich Edson engaged in a debate with guest Trey Gowdy about the looming Senate budget. Edson raised doubts about whether Republicans had managed to negotiate an advantageous deal, despite not holding sway over the Senate or White House. In response, Gowdy didn’t hold back from critiquing his own party. He highlighted that the GOP’s subpar candidate selection and lackluster election performance were at the root of their current predicament. As evidence, he referenced recent electoral disappointments. These included last November’s midterms where House Republicans fell short of expectations, and the 2021 Georgia elections which saw two Republican Senators unseated. Looking ahead, Gowdy sounded an alarm about potential repercussions if Democrats seize control of all three branches — House, Senate, and White House. He warned that a detrimental budget bill would be unavoidable in such circumstances. The responsibility for this possible outcome? According to Gowdy, it rests squarely on GOP shoulders due to their poor candidate choices and failure to secure winnable elections.
Stay updated with more news by following Pam Key on Twitter @pamkeyNEN.
MCQUADE’S SHOCKING Comparison: Trump’s Tactics Mirror Hitler and Mussolini?
— Former U.S. Attorney Barbara McQuade has sparked controversy by comparing President Trump’s tactics to those of infamous dictators Adolf Hitler and Benito Mussolini. She suggests that Trump’s use of simple, repeatable slogans like “Stop the Steal” reflects strategies used by these historical figures.
McQuade also argues that Trump’s claim of a stolen election is a “big lie.” She believes this tactic, ironically, gains credibility due to its sheer size. According to her, such strategies have been seen in the actions of notorious leaders like Hitler and Mussolini throughout history.
In addition, she criticized today’s media environment. McQuade suggests that people are creating their own “news bubbles,” leading to an echo-chamber effect where they only encounter ideas that support their existing views.
Her remarks have ignited intense debates on social media platforms. Critics argue her comparison is overly dramatic while supporters think it underscores serious problems in our political dialogue.
TRUMP’S EYE on Burgum: A Potential Power Player in Second Administration
— Doug Burgum, the Governor of North Dakota, has recently been spotlighted by former President Trump as a potential key player for his possible second term. This news emerged following Trump’s unprecedented victory in the Iowa Caucuses.
Responding to conjecture about a potential role in Trump’s administration, Burgum, who had previously endorsed Trump just before the Iowa Caucuses said, “Well, it’s very flattering... but you know, these are all hypotheticals.”
The Governor underscored his dedication to his current position and to backing Trump’s nomination and election endeavors. He further explained that his previous campaign was motivated by concerns about the economy, energy and national security issues that America is facing.
GAME-CHANGER or Political Suicide? House Republicans Ponder Biden Impeachment
— Under the guidance of Speaker Mike Johnson (R-LA), House Republicans are contemplating the impeachment of President Joe Biden. This idea stems from numerous 2023 investigations into both Biden and his son, Hunter, who are accused of exploiting their family name for personal gain.
The decision to impeach could be a tricky one for Republicans. On one hand, it could resonate with their core supporters as payback against Democrats’ previous attempts to impeach ex-President Donald Trump. On the other hand, it might push away independent voters and undecided Democrats.
Calls for Biden’s impeachment aren’t recent developments. Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-GA) has advocated for investigations into the president since he took office. With an ongoing inquiry and years worth of evidence gathered, Speaker Johnson might sanction an impeachment vote as soon as February 2024.
Nevertheless, this strategy carries significant risk. The evidence put forth by House Republicans against Biden seems vague at best, and initiating an inquiry doesn’t necessarily imply backing for impeachment itself — a point that 17 Republican House members from districts won by Biden in 2020 are eager to emphasize to their voters.
TRUMP BACKLASH: Former Arkansas Governor Booed at Florida Freedom Summit Over Anti-Trump Remarks
— Asa Hutchinson, the former governor of Arkansas, was met with a chorus of boos during his speech at the Florida Freedom Summit. This strong reaction from the crowd was triggered when Hutchinson hinted that Donald Trump could potentially face a felony conviction by a jury next year.
Having served as both a federal prosecutor and representative, Hutchinson is currently not making any waves in the Republican primary race with his polling numbers flatlining at zero percent. His remarks sparked widespread disapproval among the more than 3,000 attendees present at the event.
Despite facing an unfavorable response from his audience, Hutchinson didn’t back down. He maintained that Trump’s potential legal troubles could sway independent voters’ view of the party and influence down-ticket races for Congress and Senate.
TRUMP’S FIGHT: The Fourteenth Amendment Takes Center Stage in Ballot Battle
— A brewing legal battle is placing the spotlight on the Fourteenth Amendment’s “Insurrection Clause”. Plaintiffs argue that President Trump’s actions on January 6, 2021, should bar him from appearing on future ballots.
This legal challenge is not unique to one state. Similar cases are popping up across the country, including Colorado. Here, Judge Sarah Wallace, an appointee of Democrat Governor Jared Polis, presides over the case. There is a possibility that this issue may escalate to the U.S. Supreme Court.
Trump’s defense team counters by asserting that this amendment doesn’t extend to presidents. They highlight that while it mentions Senators and Representatives among others, it does not explicitly include presidents. The presidential oath has its own separate provision in the Constitution.
JEFFRIES’ JUDGEMENT: Praises Biden, Condemns ‘Irresponsible’ Maga Republicans
— Jeffries recently commended President Biden’s leadership, emphasizing his efforts to uphold the special bond between the United States and Israel. He also underscored Biden’s commitment to Ukraine in the face of Russian aggression and his provision of humanitarian aid to Palestinians in Gaza.
The House and Senate are ready to proceed under Biden’s guidance, Jeffries stated. However, he lambasted extreme MAGA Republicans for their alleged attempts to tie aid to Israel during its conflict. Jeffries branded this move as “irresponsible,” accusing them of political isolation.
Jeffries called for a comprehensive review of President Biden’s proposed package, citing the current perilous global climate. He criticized what he perceives as partisan games played by extreme MAGA Republicans. Jeffries characterized their actions as “unfortunate” during these challenging times.
ETHICS In QUESTION: Biden Under Scrutiny as Hunter’s Investigations Intensify
— The ongoing investigations into Hunter Biden have begun to cast a significant shadow over President Joe Biden. The Justice Department, along with Republican members of Congress, are closely examining the president’s son for his alleged involvement in a criminal scheme with then-Vice President Biden. This comes alongside separate gun charges following the collapse of a plea deal on tax charges.
A recent poll indicates that 35% of U.S. adults believe the president has acted illegally, while 33% suspect unethical conduct. The investigation is spearheaded by House Oversight Committee Chairman James Comer (R-KY) and House Judiciary Committee Chairman Jim Jordan (R-OH). Their goal is to establish a connection between Hunter’s business dealings with a Ukrainian oil and gas firm and his father during his vice presidency.
Hunter Biden has been indicted by special counsel David Weiss in relation to a gun purchase in October 2018. He stands accused of violating orders prohibiting drug users from owning guns and has pleaded not guilty to all three counts against him. There are clear differences in perception across party lines: only 8% of Democrats believe the president is guilty of crimes related to his son’s activities, compared with 65% of Republicans.
As these investigations and indictments continue, they fuel growing controversy around the Bidens. This raises serious concerns about ethics at the
Video
TRUMP’S Triumph: A Historic White House Return Shakes UP America
— In a historic White House meeting, President-elect Donald Trump and President Joe Biden discussed the transition of power after Trump’s decisive 2024 election victory. This encounter marked Trump’s first return to the White House since his win, setting a cooperative tone for the transition period. Despite past political rivalry, both leaders showed professionalism and mutual respect.
Their conversation focused on key topics, including strategies from Biden’s administration and ensuring a smooth handover of duties. Trump expressed gratitude for Biden’s willingness to facilitate constructive dialogue, reinforcing America’s tradition of peaceful leadership transitions. The atmosphere was cordial as both parties aimed to maintain national stability during this period.
Trump’s victory across all seven battleground states highlights his strong political comeback amid a dynamic landscape. Meanwhile, Biden’s party is introspecting and planning future strategies following the unexpected electoral outcome. The meeting is expected to lead to further collaboration on critical national and foreign policy issues during the transition.
The media spotlighted this meeting as a reaffirmation of democratic processes amidst global political volatility. As Trump prepares to take office again, there is significant anticipation about how his leadership will shape America’s future while upholding democratic values during electoral transitions.
More Videos
Invalid Query
The keyword entered was invalid, or we couldn't gather enough relevant information to construct a thread. Try checking the spelling or entering a broader search term. Often simple one-word terms are enough for our algorithms to build a detailed thread on the topic. Longer multi-word terms will refine the search but create a narrower information thread.
Chatter
What the world is saying!
Today, on Transgender Day of Remembrance, we mourn the transgender Americans whose lives were taken this year in horrific acts of violence. Every American deserves to be treated with dignity,...
. . .Whether in women’s sports, our public schools, or our federal government, women should not have their private spaces invaded by men. Thank you @SpeakerJohnson for this common sense decision.
. . .In 1995, Jodi Huisentruit was on her way to work as a morning news anchor in Mason City, Iowa. But she never arrived at the station. Decades after her disappearance, new tips have led investigators...
. . .ICYMI: Our Friday contribution to @CBSMornings. @thomasrhanson embeds with elite firefighters from the NJ Forest Fire Service.
. . .Giving young organizers a seat at the table is critical to winning elections. Proud of our Coordinated Campaign for this massive increase in young voter turnout and for electing Democrats up...
. . .TOMORROW: @NYCMayor Eric Adams joins us at the #HotTopics table.
. . .Opinion | RFK Jr.’s views on fluoride aren’t as crazy as you might think, Leana Wen writes.
. . .On Veterans Day, we owe our veterans and their families our thanks, our respect, and our freedom. To all those who bravely served, thank you for your service to our country.
. . .Setbacks are unavoidable, but giving up is unforgivable. As my dad would say, we all get knocked down—but the measure of our character is how quickly we get up. A defeat does not mean we...
. . .America's 250th birthday. The 2026 #WorldCup in the #USA The 2028 #LosAngeles #Olympics Our return to the moon, orbiting in 2025 and landing in 2026 #Trump will be President for all of it,...
. . .MARK PENN: Trump's triumph sends major message. It's the working class and middle America that run our country
. . .Trump's triumph sends major message. It's the working class and middle America that run our country
. . .What America saw today was the Kamala Harris I know and deeply admire. She’s been a tremendous partner and public servant full of integrity, courage, and character. Under extraordinary circumstan...
. . .AOC Hit With Community Note After Claiming Puerto Rican Rally Had to Do With Anti-Trump Movement #AOC #FactChecking
. . .Trump +5 in Iowa GOP internal this year, when he won the state by 8 in 2020 and 9 in 2016, sets off its own alarm bells.
. . .When I took office, we faced the worst economic crisis since the Great Depression. Today, we have the greatest economy in the world.
. . .One London Tory: "Whilst I think Trump is a revolting misogynist, rapist, narcissist, Putin-apologist, danger to the global order and the west, I suspect he will probably be good for the U.S....
. . .I voted early, and I hope you do too. This is the most important election of our lifetimes. I know @KamalaHarris will do one hell of a job as our next president. Make your plan to vote: http://IWil...
. . .“it is quite difficult to Trump-proof agencies and programs from someone who is determined to break the guardrails and shift the direction of the country ..." said Sen. Chris Coons, a Delaware...
. . .As one of the Marines sent to fight your daddy’s bullshit war I just need you to know active duty and veterans say this about you and those like you all the time. We are not petty, vindictive,...
. . .Can’t watch any more of this. What a truly disgraceful Yankees performance. If I were Gerrit Cole I’d sue the whole damned team ands Boone too. #NYY #WorldSeries2024
. . .5 DAYS OUT: The Trump campaign has staged another can’t-look-away campaign event to drive a message But don’t look at it and miss what he’s been saying repeatedly, even when dressed in...
. . .THIS IS THE STORY I’VE BEEN YELLING FOR SOMEONE TO DO. ?@IvankaTrump? was omnipresent favorite daughter … and now she’s living her best life as far from her father’s orbit as possible....
. . .U.S. Navy Reserve Officer Sentenced for Bribery Scheme Involving Department of State’s Approval Process for Special Immigrant Visas First Sentence for Defendant Related to Afghan Allies Protectio...
. . .Typical Trump MAGA.. Insults, hate, and fear. This is the currency that they trade in. #Cult45 #Trump2024 #puertorico
. . .WHEN I’M PRESIDENT THE MCDONALD’S ICE CREAM MACHINES WILL WORK GREAT AGAIN!
. . .'You can’t let him win': @JoeBiden pleads with union workers to defeat @realDonaldTrump
. . .Just imagine the Oval Office in three months: It’s either Donald Trump in there, stewing over his enemies list—or me, working for you, checking off my to-do list.
. . .So great to have you at the Roundtable!
. . .I've had some terrific conversations on my book tour for "Something Lost, Something Gained"—and the final leg begins this weekend! If you're in Atlanta, Detroit, New York, or Tampa, don't...
. . .Preliminary Injunction Entered in Justice Department Suit to Stop Virginia’s Systematic Removal of Voters from Registration Rolls ?: https://justice.gov/opa/pr/preliminary-injunction-entered-j...
. . .Harris doubled Trump's fundraising in first two weeks of October and has a huge cash advantage. So of course, the NYT headline lead is "both candidates spent a lot of money and Trump has now...
. . .Former Federal Employee Pleads Guilty to Mishandling Classified Materials ?: https://justice.gov/opa/pr/former-federal-employee-pleads-guilty-mishandling-classified-materials…
. . .